Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Double Standard for Israel


Here's a letter to the editor I sent to the Washington Post in response to this article about Mitt Romney's comments about Palestinian culture. I will update if it is published.

 Double Standards for Israel

Reading Marc A. Thiessen’s August 1st article “There was no Romney gaffe in Israel” begs the question: would Mr. Thiessen support the same standards he applies to Palestinians if they were applied to Israel?

For example, Thiessen justifies Israel’s blockade, which has been estimated to cost Gaza’s economy $2 billion a year [1], and Israel’s illegal trade restrictions in the West Bank by referring to the “culture of terrorism that permeates the Palestinian territories.” Conspicuously absent from Thiessen’s account is any mention Israel’s “culture of terrorism” or their heavily militarized culture and how this may have affected their society.

This absence is particularly striking when one considers the Israeli human rights organization B'Tselem estimate that 6,000 Palestinians have been killed since the year 2000, , which is 5,000 more causalities than Israel has experienced during the same period [2].

With this in mind, if, as Thiessen suggests, Palestinian terrorism justifies Israel’s blockade, restriction and occupation of Palestinian territory, do Palestinians have the right to apply the same policies to Israel?



1. "Israeli occupation hitting Palestinian economy, claims report,” Harriet Sherwood, The Guardian,September 29, 2011. (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/sep/29/israeli-occupation-hits-palestinian-economy)

2. http://old.btselem.org/statistics/english/Casualties.asp